Guidelines for Reviewers

Blind Peer Review Sheet 

Some criteria to consider include but are not limited to:

→    The educational significance of the paper as it pertains to the issue’s theme;
→    its general significance and relevance within the Caribbean;
→    a well-structured and well-researched conceptual framework;
→    Overall development and presentation – e.g. organization, evidence of research, argumentation/analysis, use of language, and readability.
→    Type of paper – e.g. analytical, descriptive, or other.

N.B. You may also refer to the information pertaining to content on the Guidelines for Contributors
document.

Recommendation:

• ACCEPT
• ACCEPT PENDING MINOR REVISION
• ACCEPT PENDING MAJOR REVISION
• REJECT

Detailed Commentary: